MOTORCYCLE Type
Make and model
Year
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight Cruiser reviews
Reliability
5.0
Overall quality
5.0
Performance
4.8
Comfort
4.6
Top 10 Cruisers
Reviews
Stars Refinement
8 ratings and reviews
Voted most helpful review
Mike Moreland
Danville, Ohio
Reviewed on April 4, 2009
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
For its size, it handles like a much smaller bike. It corners great, especially when you scrape the floorboards! Shifting is very smooth. I have added countless chrome accessories. This bike is a real head turner....
read more
For its size, it handles like a much smaller bike. It corners great, especially when you scrape the floorboards! Shifting is very smooth. I have added countless chrome accessories. This bike is a real head turner.
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
4.0
Voted most helpful review
BIGB
Milpitas, California
Reviewed on April 7, 2007
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
Before Midnight Star, I was a HD buyer. But after I saw this bike, I forgot about HD. The performance, handling, looks, power, sounds and most important thing which is half the price of HD. I'm very pleased with my bike. I have since 2004 and I will keep it forever. So if you're thinking about getting a big b...
read more
Before Midnight Star, I was a HD buyer. But after I saw this bike, I forgot about HD. The performance, handling, looks, power, sounds and most important thing which is half the price of HD. I'm very pleased with my bike. I have since 2004 and I will keep it forever. So if you're thinking about getting a big bike, then go for Midnight Star. I love it, it's my black baby. It has lots of power and runs very smooth.
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Voted most helpful review
1meanmidnight
Imperial, Pennsylvania
Reviewed on June 3, 2005
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
I have had my 04 midnight star for a year now and it doesn't come back to the garage with less then 100 miles per trip! I haven't found a HD that will hang with it! This is the most reliable bike on the road. Why would anyone buy a HD for twice the money and get an underpowered motor, poor bakes, and poor rel...
read more
I have had my 04 midnight star for a year now and it doesn't come back to the garage with less then 100 miles per trip! I haven't found a HD that will hang with it! This is the most reliable bike on the road. Why would anyone buy a HD for twice the money and get an underpowered motor, poor bakes, and poor reliability?
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Voted most helpful review
LuckyJim
Duncanville, Texas
Reviewed on April 28, 2005
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
I bought this used about a month ago when it had 4,900 miles... just broken in! Traded in my 2003 1100 V Star because I wanted more power. Very comfortable, amazing power and torque, gets looks wherever I go. Previous owner really decked it out. Finally, the price to value ratio can't be beat. Paid HALF of wh...
read more
I bought this used about a month ago when it had 4,900 miles... just broken in! Traded in my 2003 1100 V Star because I wanted more power. Very comfortable, amazing power and torque, gets looks wherever I go. Previous owner really decked it out. Finally, the price to value ratio can't be beat. Paid HALF of what a similarly equiped used Harley model would be. What a cruiser. Yamaha just gets better and better.
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Dave
Hartford, Connecticut
Reviewed on July 9, 2004
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

4.0
Just sold my 2003 Intruder 1500 and bought the Roadie. I changed because of the lack of accessories available for the 1500, and the lack of detail in its fit and finish. In hindsight, this may not have been the best reason. However, the Roadie is a better looking product, with much more attention to detail an...
read more
Just sold my 2003 Intruder 1500 and bought the Roadie. I changed because of the lack of accessories available for the 1500, and the lack of detail in its fit and finish. In hindsight, this may not have been the best reason. However, the Roadie is a better looking product, with much more attention to detail and lots of options in terms of customizing. It performs, handles, and rides beautifully. I would have prefered spoked rims to the cast, and I do miss the size of the Intruder (I am 6'2"). All in all I'm quite pleased and am looking forward to the many changes ahead.
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Voted most helpful review
Andrew Mangin
Davie, Florida
Reviewed on July 1, 2004
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
This is the first cruiser that I have bought after deciding to give up on the sport bike scene. I love this bike, it is really powerful and has a nice feel to it through the powerband. My days of sportbikes are over. Great bike!...
read more
This is the first cruiser that I have bought after deciding to give up on the sport bike scene. I love this bike, it is really powerful and has a nice feel to it through the powerband. My days of sportbikes are over. Great bike!
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
Voted most helpful review
Gerry
Bishop, California
Reviewed on May 25, 2004
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
This bike is really a very fine machine. It has the looks of a Harley but is less expensive to purchase and to insure. It is dependable, has good low end power and is stable on the road. It is great on the straights but a bit slow in the turns. It is a cruiser so it cruises. I experience butt burn at about 20...
read more
This bike is really a very fine machine. It has the looks of a Harley but is less expensive to purchase and to insure. It is dependable, has good low end power and is stable on the road. It is great on the straights but a bit slow in the turns. It is a cruiser so it cruises. I experience butt burn at about 200 miles but I think that after market seats are available to overcome this problem. The bike would benefit from exhaust that has some character, Hard Chrome has a great setup. I recommend this bike to anyone interested in a good, heavy cruiser. I am an older rider that appreciates quality and safety in a motorcycle. This has those qualities!
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
4.0
Comfort
4.0
Voted most helpful review
Chuck
Tonopah, Arizona
Reviewed on May 23, 2004
Motorcycle reviewed
2004 Yamaha Road Star Midnight

5.0
haven't ridden in years, and even then I wasn't riding big motorcycles. I was a little anxious riding this bike at first because of it's size, and it took a few days to get used to it. After four days of short 10 to 65 mile jaunts, I'm very comfortable on this bike, and since it handles as well as it does, it...
read more
haven't ridden in years, and even then I wasn't riding big motorcycles. I was a little anxious riding this bike at first because of it's size, and it took a few days to get used to it. After four days of short 10 to 65 mile jaunts, I'm very comfortable on this bike, and since it handles as well as it does, it feels like an old shoe. So far, I'm very happy that I bought this bike. It's beautiful, handles really well, and has plenty of power. Thumbs up Yamaha!
Reliability
5.0
Quality
5.0
Performance
5.0
Comfort
5.0
- 1
1 - 8 of 8 reviews